The Thursday Plate · Atlanta's best bites in your inbox every weekJoin free →
Subscribe
Reviews · McDonough · Henry County

DaVinci’s NY Style Pizza in McDonough, GA: Does It Live Up to the Hype?

By What Atlanta EatsPizza · Lunch1035 GA-155 S, McDonoughOrder now ↗
6/10
A decent slice, but room for improvementGood foldable crust and standout marinara; skimpy sauce and cheese held it back.
Pepperoni and mushroom New York-style slice at DaVinci's NY Style Pizza in McDonough
The pepperoni and mushroom slice from the $8.99 lunch special.

Pizza is pretty much my ride or die, so when I heard that DaVinci’s NY Style Pizza in McDonough, GA, had won a Taste of Henry award, I knew I had to check it out. Award-winning pizza? Say less.

We stopped in on a Monday around lunchtime, and the restaurant was surprisingly quiet. On the bright side, we had our pick of tables. There appeared to be just one waitress working the dining room, but she was attentive, polite, and handled things well.

Let’s talk about the food

DaVinci’s offers lunch specials, so I went with the one-slice, two-topping pizza special with a drink for $8.99. I chose pepperoni and mushrooms. My dining companion ordered a small White Out specialty pizza, and we decided to share an order of garlic knots.

First up: the garlic knots

The garlic knots arrived in a baking tin, which immediately had me wondering: Are these made from scratch or pre-made? I’m not saying they weren’t homemade, but the presentation had me questioning.

Flavor-wise, they were decent. My biggest complaint was the garlic butter situation. Most of it had pooled at the bottom of the tin instead of coating the knots where it belonged. I wanted buttery, garlicky goodness in every bite, not a puddle underneath.

Garlic knots in a foil baking tin with a cup of marinara at DaVinci's NY Style Pizza
Garlic knots, served in the tin, with the standout marinara.

Now, the marinara sauce? That was a standout! Rich, flavorful, and easily one of the best things I tasted during this visit. I’d gladly take another helping of that.

The main event: pepperoni & mushroom pizza

When it comes to New York-style pizza, I have expectations. Give me a thin crust, a good fold, flavorful sauce, and enough cheese to make every bite worthwhile.

DaVinci’s got the crust right. It was thin, foldable, and exactly the style I enjoy.

Unfortunately, the pizza didn’t quite deliver beyond the crust. The sauce was a little skimpy, and the cheese could have been more generous. I would have liked a little more of both to balance out that otherwise enjoyable crust. For a place advertising New York-style pizza, the crust was on point, but the overall slice left me wanting more.

The White Out pizza

My dining companion went with the White Out, a thin-crust specialty pizza featuring a garlic olive oil base, ricotta, Parmesan, and mozzarella cheeses.

Small White Out white pizza with ricotta, Parmesan and mozzarella on a garlic olive oil base at DaVinci's
The White Out: garlic olive oil, ricotta, Parmesan and mozzarella.

He enjoyed it, so DaVinci’s earned some points there. If you’re a fan of white pizzas and prefer something without traditional tomato sauce, this might be worth a try.

A word about the restroom

I always check out the restroom when reviewing a restaurant. Call me picky, but I believe the condition of a restaurant’s restroom says something about its overall attention to detail and cleanliness.

Unfortunately, the ladies’ restroom needed some attention. It’s one of those little things that can leave a lasting impression, and not necessarily a good one.

The final verdict: 6/10

DaVinci’s NY Style Pizza wasn’t a bad lunch, but it wasn’t one that knocked my socks off, either.

What worked

  • Friendly, attentive service
  • Thin, foldable New York-style crust
  • Rich, flavorful marinara
  • The White Out pizza

What didn’t

  • Skimpy sauce and cheese on the slice
  • Garlic butter pooled in the tin, not on the knots
  • Ladies’ restroom needed attention

Would I go back? Absolutely.

I’m not ready to write DaVinci’s off after one visit. In fact, I’ve already got my eye on the wings and the chicken Parmesan sandwich for round two.

The menu also includes Philly cheesesteaks, strombolis, and calzones, so there’s plenty more to explore.

My take: If you’re in the McDonough area and craving a slice, DaVinci’s is an okay option. Just don’t expect a life-changing pizza experience based on my visit.

6/10
Final scoreMiddle of the pack, with a crust and marinara worth a return visit.

Have you tried DaVinci’s NY Style Pizza?

Did I catch them on an off day, or was your experience similar? Let me know, and tag us when you post your slice.

Order from DaVinci’s ↗← More reviews